The 15 Best Places for Pizza in Toledo (2024)

1.Pizza Papalis

8.4

519 Monroe St (at N Huron St), Toledo, OH

Pizzeria · Warehouse Entertainment District · 46 tips and reviews

Burkett Restaurant Equipment:Great Pizza..its huge! Great atmosphere also, check it out if your in town. Its right near the new Arena.

Stephanie Wise:Forget the rest of the menu! Deep dish is just as good as Chicago deep dish!

Emily Babco*ck:The pizza is so so good. Deep dish is worth the wait for sure

2.Home Slice Pizza

8.5

28 S Saint Clair St (btwn Washington St & Lafayette St), Toledo, OH

Pizzeria · Warehouse Entertainment District · 20 tips and reviews

Craig Jablonski:Great lunch special - the 2 pieces of pizza are huge!

Steven Brown:Great pizza!!! Good drink specials!

Barry Heisler:Best thin crust pizza anywhere. Always some good beer on tap.

3.Inky's

8.2

3945 N Detroit Ave (at W Sylvania Ave), Toledo, OH

Italian Restaurant · Five Points - Library Village · 28 tips and reviews

Brooke Paul:Great local Italian food and thin crust pizzas.

Paul Wisner:Pizza pie is best in toledo:-)

Toni-Lynn Kalucki:Definitely the best pizza in Toledo!

Lindsay Freeman:House bread is amazing and you can't go wrong with any of their pizzas.

MFR:Best gluten free pizza in Toledo!

MFR:Hands down the best gluten free pizza in town!!!!

5.The Original Gino's Pizza

8.3

3981 Monroe St (at W Central Ave), Toledo, OH

Pizzeria · Ottawa · 15 tips and reviews

LaDale Whaley:Best Pizza in the City!

Ina Sidney:GINO'S PIZZA IS THE BEST PIZZA AROUND!!! Nobody can touch them!!!

Emad Mikhail:Best pizza in Toledo..

6.Shawn's Irish Tavern

8.0

4400 Heatherdowns Blvd (Key), Toledo, OH

Irish Pub · 18 tips and reviews

Jessica:Best bar in South Toledo... The only bar as far as I'm concerned. Free popcorn, great apps, best pizza.

Katie J:This pizza is very good! And popcorn!!

Wally Anderson:Great thin crust pizza

7.Jo-Jo's Original Pizzeria

7.7

4336 Monroe St, Toledo, OH

Pizzeria · 19 tips and reviews

Toledo Blade:The Blade's review: Jo-Jo's Original Pizzeria ***Pizza’s the star on diverse menu http://tol.bz/becl1P Read more.

Ricky "The Bull":1/2 off pizza!!! Mon and wed get a large for $5.00

Eric Valentine:Best place to grab a pizza and beer. 1/2 price pizza Monday and Wed nights. $1 beers every day all day at Papa Joes!

8.ZaZa Wood-Fired Pizza

7.5

3550 Executive Pkwy (at Secor Rd), Toledo, OH

Pizzeria · Westgate, Toledo, OH · 11 tips and reviews

Stephanie K:great pizza

Julie Fain:Awesome lunch deal for two: a 1 topping pizza, any large salad, and 2 fountain drinks for $15.99!

Valerie Coulter:The BEST pizza and their spinach salad is the best in town!!

9.Maumee Bay Brewing Company

8.7

27 Broadway St #A, Toledo, OH

Brewery · Warehouse Entertainment District · 46 tips and reviews

Bryan Gardner:Fantastic service! Great meal! Better beer! Try the sampler, the pretzel and the pizzas!

Jordan Justice:Pizza and the giant pretzel are two of my favorite menu items. Best beers? Amarillo Brillo and Total Eclipse.

C J:Ask to be seated in the back room, with a view of the river (vs. the bar). Also, 🍕 is made in wood-fired brick oven!

10.Penn Station East Coast Subs

8.5

1266 S Holland Sylvania Rd, Toledo, OH

Sandwich Spot · 12 tips and reviews

Dawn Boyce:The pizza sub here is amazing. And the fresh cut fries with vinaiger...also amazing.

Phil Savitt:Get a pizza sub with sausage and mushrooms added because its good to have. Get a lemonade and cookie to go with that as well because they are also good to have

Obi Strong:About to try the pizza sub with sausage (same as phil savitt) we will see

11.The Stubborn Brother Pizza Bar

7.7

3121 W Bancroft St, Toledo, OH

Pizzeria · 3 tips and reviews

Darek Chelminiak:Good atmosphere but food is pricey. $22 for a pizza seems a bit much. It did taste good though.

Marcia Voss:Delicious pizza! Pretty pricy but they are HUGE and the taste is delicious!!! I highly recommend!

STEVE KIZEWIC:Salad amazing. Best pizza i ever ate. Crust was amazing. Service was great! Chocolate soft serve with salted caramel. Simply fantastic.

7.5

4466 Monroe St, Toledo, OH

Pizzeria · 3 tips and reviews

Herman H.:Pizza, wings, salads, or breadsticks....they've got deals! Dont forget to tip your delivery driver!

Charese Foster:One of the best pizza places ever!!!!

Ahmed Allaith:Great one of the best in Toledo

13.J-Cups Pizza

7.2

3265 W Alexis Rd (at Secor Rd), Toledo, OH

Pizzeria · Whitmer-Trilby · 4 tips and reviews

Andy Bockrath:Pretty good pizza at a reasonable price.

Kevin Brown:Best pizza for the value in town hands down. BBQ pork pizza is fantastic. Better than Vito's BBQ chicken. Well done J-Cups!

Gina G.:Makes a decent local gluten free pizza.

14.Grumpy's Restaurant

8.5

34 S Huron St (at Lafayette St), Toledo, OH

American Restaurant · Warehouse Entertainment District · 23 tips and reviews

Lauren Kovarik:Eggs Benedict Pizza is GREAT! The flavors all blend together to make one tasty treat 😊

alana marie edmunds:Go here. Get a garbage salad. Leave happy.

Josh Sponsler:Its a crime that they are not open on the weekends.

15.Hungry Howie's Pizza

7.1

5820 Douglas Ave, Toledo, OH

Pizzeria · Whitmer-Trilby · 8 tips and reviews

Noemi Kassis:Found a great tip! 20% Off Pizza http://bit.ly/sUIFc5 Read more.

Monique Gustavson:Found a great tip! 20% Off Pizza http://bit.ly/uPY8em Read more.

Gina G.:Careful. I don't believe people that work here are very clean. I once found a mustache hair on my pizza.

The 15 Best Places for Pizza in Toledo (2024)

References

Top Articles
Latest Posts
Article information

Author: Geoffrey Lueilwitz

Last Updated:

Views: 5490

Rating: 5 / 5 (60 voted)

Reviews: 91% of readers found this page helpful

Author information

Name: Geoffrey Lueilwitz

Birthday: 1997-03-23

Address: 74183 Thomas Course, Port Micheal, OK 55446-1529

Phone: +13408645881558

Job: Global Representative

Hobby: Sailing, Vehicle restoration, Rowing, Ghost hunting, Scrapbooking, Rugby, Board sports

Introduction: My name is Geoffrey Lueilwitz, I am a zealous, encouraging, sparkling, enchanting, graceful, faithful, nice person who loves writing and wants to share my knowledge and understanding with you.